Blog

Cat litter brands compared: lab scores for 14 brands

We lab-tested 32 litters from the 14 brands with two or more on our list. See every score, and why one brand's litters can differ by 22 points.

Published . Figures from The Litter Index 2026.

The short answer

Fourteen brands have two or more litters in The Litter Index 2026, 32 litters in all. A brand name is only a rough guide: litters from the same brand differed by up to 22 points out of 100, and 7 of the 14 brands had litters in more than one score tier. In all five brands with both a clay and a non-clay litter on the list, the clay litter scored lowest.

It is easy to shop by brand name. If one litter from a brand worked well, it seems fair to expect the same from its others. We tested that against the scores.

Fourteen brands have two or more litters in this year’s Litter Index, 32 litters in all. This post shows how each brand’s litters scored, how far apart litters from the same brand landed, and what changed when a brand used a different material.

Jump to:

How we grouped the brands

We grouped litters by the brand name at the start of each product name. We did not group brands by parent company. Every brand with two or more litters on this year’s list is included, so no brand is picked out or left out.

Each litter went through the same five tests: dust, clumping, odour, tracking and sustainability. Each test is scored from 0 to 5 in half points, and the total is out of 100. The method page explains each test. We bought every litter at retail, and no brand can pay for a place.

The other 18 litters on the list come from brands with one litter each. Their scores are in the Index too.

Is a cat litter brand a good guide to its score?

Only partly. Litters from the same brand differed by up to 22 points out of 100, and 7 of the 14 brands had litters in more than one of our score tiers.

Our tiers run in steps of 10 points: 90 and over, 80 to 89, 70 to 79, 60 to 69, and under 60. The average across all 50 litters was 79.

Gap between a brand’s highest and lowest totalBrands
0 points3
1 to 9 points5
10 to 19 points5
20 or more points1

Three brands scored the same total for both of their litters. Six brands had a gap of 10 points or more.

Every brand with two or more litters

Brands are listed in alphabetical order. Totals run from highest to lowest, and the gap is the highest total minus the lowest.

BrandLittersTotalsGap
Arm & Hammer292, 920
Biokat’s284, 6618
Dr. Elsey’s266, 624
Fukumaru272, 702
Homerun282, 7210
Iris Ohyama276, 724
Lorde292, 8012
Michu278, 780
OdourLock284, 786
Petabite292, 920
Petshy282, 7210
Pidan696, 92, 88, 86, 82, 7422
Tigerino276, 706
Tofu Cat Litter Australia298, 8414

Pidan is the only brand with more than two litters on the list. Its six litters cover four of the six litter types, which helps explain the 22-point gap.

Same brand, different material

Ten of the 14 brands have litters made from different materials. Five of them have both a clay litter and a non-clay litter on the list. In all five, the clay litter had the brand’s lowest total.

BrandClay litterOther litters
Fukumaru7072
Homerun7282
Iris Ohyama7276
Pidan7482 to 96
Tigerino7076

Where the points went differed by brand.

  • Pidan: the clay litter scored 3.5 for dust and 3 for sustainability. Its five other litters all scored 4.5 or 5 for dust.
  • Homerun: the cassava litter scored 4 for sustainability against 2 for the clay one, and 5 for dust against 4.
  • Tigerino: the tofu litter scored 4 for dust against 3, and 3 for sustainability against 2.
  • Iris Ohyama: the paper litter scored 5 for sustainability against 2. The clay litter scored higher for clumping and odour, 4 against 3 on each.
  • Fukumaru: the blend scored 4 for tracking against 3. The clay litter clumped better, 4.5 against 4.

Clay litters often score lower for sustainability, because our checklist rates renewable, biodegradable materials highest. We explain the checklist in how each material scored for sustainability. A clay litter can still do well overall: three of the top 10 litters this year are clay.

Same brand, same material

Four brands have two litters of the same type, and all four are clay. Their gaps ran from 0 to 18 points, so even the same material from the same brand is no guarantee.

BrandTotalsGap
Arm & Hammer92, 920
Dr. Elsey’s66, 624
OdourLock84, 786
Biokat’s84, 6618

Arm & Hammer’s two litters scored the same on all five tests.

Biokat’s two litters had the widest gap. The lower-scoring one scored lower on every one of the five tests, including tracking, where the two scored 5 and 3.5.

OdourLock’s two litters matched on clumping, odour and tracking. The gap came from dust (4.5 against 4) and sustainability (3 against 2).

Dr. Elsey’s two litters matched on dust, odour and sustainability, and differed by half a point on clumping and tracking.

All 32 litters, in rank order

The rank is the litter’s place among all 50.

RankLitterTypeTotal
1Tofu Cat Litter Australia, OriginalTofu and soy98
2Pidan Original Tofu Cat LitterTofu and soy96
4Petabite, Snow Cat LitterCassava92
5Arm & Hammer HardballClay92
6Arm & Hammer Clump and SealClay92
7Pidan Cassava Cat LitterCassava92
8Petabite, Terra Cat LitterBlend92
9Lorde Cassava Cat LitterCassava92
12Pidan 3 in 1 Mixed Cat LitterBlend88
14Pidan Cassava & Tofu Cat LitterBlend86
15Tofu Cat Litter Australia, OatWood, paper and grain84
16OdourLock OriginalClay84
17Biokat’s Classic Fresh 3 in 1Clay84
18Pidan Tofu & Bentonite Cat LitterBlend82
19Petshy Cassava Cat LitterCassava82
20Homerun Cassava Cat LitterCassava82
24Lorde Mixed Cat LitterBlend80
26OdourLock Max CareClay78
27Michu Tofu Cat LitterTofu and soy78
29Michu Wonder LitterCassava78
30Iris Ohyama Flushable PaperWood, paper and grain76
31Tigerino Plant Based LitterTofu and soy76
32Pidan Bentonite Cat LitterClay74
36Petshy Mixed Cat LitterBlend72
37Iris Ohyama BentoniteClay72
38Fukumaru Mixed Cat LitterBlend72
39Homerun Bentonite Cat LitterClay72
42Tigerino Premium Cat LitterClay70
43Fukumaru Bentonite Cat LitterClay70
46Dr. Elsey’s Ultra LitterClay66
47Biokat’s Diamond CareClay66
49Dr. Elsey’s Classic LitterClay62

Blends mix two or more of tofu, cassava and clay. We list “Iris Ohyama Flushable Paper” by its name on the bag; we never recommend flushing cat litter.

How to use a brand name when you shop

This section is our judgement, based on the scores above.

  • Treat a brand name as a starting point, not a score. Half of the 14 brands had litters in more than one tier.
  • Check the material as well as the brand. In all five brands with both a clay and a non-clay litter on the list, the clay litter scored lowest.
  • If you liked one litter from a brand and want to try another, look up that litter’s own five scores first.
  • If you are choosing between two litters from the same brand, look at which tests differ. The gap is often in one or two tests, not all five.

To put two or three litters side by side on all five tests, compare them on one page. To see how each material scored on average, see the litter types and their averages.