Blog

How sustainable is cat litter? Each material, scored

What we check when we score cat litter for sustainability, and how each material did: cassava and tofu averaged above 4 out of 5, clay 2.5.

Published . Figures from The Litter Index 2026.

The short answer

In The Litter Index 2026, cassava litters (4.36 out of 5) and tofu and soy litters (4.22) scored best for sustainability on average, and clay scored lowest of the main types (2.52). Six of the 50 litters scored a full 5. A plant-based label did not guarantee a high score: wood, paper and grain litters ranged from 2 to 5.

“Natural”, “eco” and “flushable” appear on a lot of litter bags. None of those words is a standard, so we score sustainability against a fixed checklist instead.

This post explains what we check and how each material did across The Litter Index 2026. It matters if you want a lower-impact litter, because the label and the score often disagree.

Jump to:

What “sustainable” means in our scores

Sustainability is one of the five tests behind every score in The Litter Index. It is different from the other four: it is an evidence checklist against named standards, not a bench test. We check four things.

  • Material. Renewable, biodegradable plant material such as tofu, cassava or recycled paper rates highest. Sodium bentonite clay, which is strip-mined and neither renewable nor biodegradable, rates lowest. Silica sits between.
  • Certification. We look for real compost certification (ASTM D6400 or D6868, or EN 13432), not a vague “natural” label.
  • Disposal claims. We treat “flushable” and “septic safe” claims with scrutiny, and we never tell you to flush cat waste.
  • Packaging. Recyclable or recycled content beats single-use plastic.

A score of 5 means renewable, certified compostable, a recyclable pack and claims we could verify. A score of 2 means mostly clay or heavy on plastic, with little to offset it. The full scale is on the method page.

Which type of cat litter is most sustainable?

Cassava litters scored highest on average (4.36 out of 5), followed closely by tofu and soy (4.22). Clay scored lowest of the main types (2.52).

Type of litterTestedAverage out of 5Range
Cassava74.364 to 5
Tofu and soy94.223 to 5
Wood, paper and grain63.752 to 5
Blends73.142 to 4
Clay202.522 to 4
Silica12.002

Three things stand out.

Clay sits at the bottom of the main types. Thirteen of the 20 clay litters scored 2, and none scored above 4. Any clay content also pulled blends down: no blend scored above 4. For how clay compares on the other four tests, see tofu vs clay cat litter.

Plant-based does not automatically mean a high score. The wood, paper and grain group had the widest range, from 2 to 5. The material is only one of the four checks; certification, disposal claims and packaging count too.

Only one silica litter is on this year’s list, so treat its figure as a single result, not an average for the material.

The six litters that scored a full 5

In rank order:

  1. Tofu Cat Litter Australia, Original (tofu), 98 out of 100 overall
  2. Petabite, Snow Cat Litter (cassava), 92
  3. Tofu Cat Litter Australia, Oat (oat), 84
  4. Aatas Cat Tofu (tofu), 80
  5. Rufus & Coco Zero Odour Natural Cat Litter (soy), 80
  6. Iris Ohyama Flushable Paper (paper), 76

A full 5 for sustainability is not a full recommendation

The overall totals in that list run from 76 to 98. A litter can be excellent on sustainability and ordinary in the box: the lowest-ranked of the six scored 3 out of 5 for both clumping and odour.

That matters for the footprint too, in our view. A litter that does not control odour or clump well tends to be changed more often, so more of it is used.

Our suggestion: start with the most sustainable litters, then check the other four scores of any litter you are considering. The compare page puts up to three side by side.

What the score does not tell you

  • It does not measure the carbon footprint of shipping a particular bag to your home.
  • It does not tell you what your local council accepts in compost or green waste. Check locally before composting any litter.
  • It is not a reason to flush litter. Whatever the bag says, we do not recommend flushing cat waste.