Blog

How to choose a cat litter: five things to measure

Dust, clumping, odour, tracking and sustainability: what each one means at home, how we measure it, and how 50 litters scored on each.

Published . Figures from The Litter Index 2026.

The short answer

Judge a cat litter on five things: dust, clumping, odour control, tracking and sustainability. Across the 50 litters in The Litter Index 2026, tracking and sustainability were the hardest to score well on, and no litter scored a full 5 on all five. Decide which one matters most in your home, then pick the best all-rounder for it.

Every bag of cat litter says roughly the same thing. This guide shows what to check instead, and how to weigh it for your own home.

It covers the five things we measure in the lab. For each one you get what it means day to day, how we test it, and how the 50 litters we ranked this year scored. By the end you will know which test matters most for you and where to find the litters that do best on it.

Jump to:

What should you look for in a cat litter?

Look at five things: dust, clumping, odour control, tracking and sustainability. Then decide which one matters most in your home, because very few litters are good at all five.

Of the 50 litters in The Litter Index 2026, none scored a full 5 on all five tests, and only 10 reached 90 out of 100 overall. This is how the 50 did on each test.

TestAverage out of 5Scored a full 5
Dust4.0610
Clumping4.279
Odour4.1811
Tracking3.935
Sustainability3.316

1. Dust

What it means at home: the cloud when you pour, and the film that settles around the box.

How we measure it: by weight, not by eye. A fixed volume of litter drops inside a sealed chamber while a fan draws the air through a filter that we weigh before and after.

What we found: material matters a lot here. Cassava litters averaged 4.86 for dust and clay litters 3.70. If dust is your main concern, start with the lowest-dust litters. We report what we measure and do not give health advice; if anyone in your home has a breathing condition, talk to a doctor or a vet.

2. Clumping

What it means at home: whether a clump lifts out in one piece. Litter that crumbles leaves dirty fragments behind, so the whole box needs changing sooner.

How we measure it: we pour 10 ml of a standard saline solution onto a level bed of litter, lift the clump onto a sieve, shake it and weigh what stays together. We look for more than 90% retained.

What we found: this was the highest-scoring test overall, with an average of 4.27. Most litters on the list clump acceptably, and nine scored a full 5. See the best clumping litters.

3. Odour

What it means at home: how long the box stays fresh between changes.

How we measure it: as a gas, not by nose. We dose the litter with a standard ammonia and urine source in a sealed vessel and read the ammonia in the air above it at set points over 72 hours. Perfume that hides a smell without controlling it shows up in the reading.

What we found: eleven litters scored a full 5, more than on any other test. See the best litters for odour control.

4. Tracking

What it means at home: litter on the floor, the rug and the bed.

How we measure it: a weighted pad is run over the litter to mimic a cat leaving the box, and we collect and weigh every granule that crosses marked lines on the floor. We also measure grain size, because larger, denser granules travel less.

What we found: this was the hardest performance test. Only five litters scored a full 5. Fine-grained litters tend to do worse: cassava litters, which were the best group for dust, averaged 3.71 for tracking. See the litters that track the least.

5. Sustainability

What it means at home: what the litter is made from, how you can dispose of it, and whether the claims on the bag hold up.

How we score it: this one is an evidence checklist, not a bench test, and we say so. We look at the material, real compost certification, disposal claims such as “flushable”, and the packaging.

What we found: this was the lowest-scoring test, with an average of 3.31, and the one with the biggest gap between materials. See the most sustainable litters, or read how each material scored for sustainability.

Then look for the best all-rounder

A litter that wins one test can lose badly on another. Once you know your priority, look at the other four scores before you choose. Two ways to do that:

If you would rather start from the material, litter types explained shows what each one is made from and how each scored on average. For the two most common choices head to head, read tofu vs clay cat litter.