Tofu vs clay cat litter: what our lab tests show
We tested 9 tofu and soy litters and 20 clay litters the same way. Tofu averaged 85 out of 100 and clay 76, but the best clay still beat most tofu.
Published . Figures from The Litter Index 2026.
In The Litter Index 2026, the 9 tofu and soy litters averaged 85 out of 100 and the 20 clay litters averaged 76. Tofu was ahead on dust, tracking and sustainability. Clay was slightly ahead on clumping and odour, and the best clay litter (94) outscored 7 of the 9 tofu litters.
Tofu and clay are the two materials most owners end up choosing between. The bags make similar promises, so we measured them instead.
This post puts 29 litters through the same five tests and compares the two groups. It matters because the gap is not where most people expect: the two are close on clumping and odour, and far apart on dust and sustainability.
Jump to:
- What we compared
- The averages, test by test
- Where tofu was ahead and where clay was ahead
- Is tofu litter better than clay?
What we compared
The Litter Index 2026 includes 9 litters made from tofu or soy and 20 made from bentonite clay. We bought all 29 at retail and ran the same five tests on each: dust, clumping, odour, tracking and sustainability. Each test is scored from 0 to 5, and the total is out of 100. The full method is here.
One note on the groups: a clay litter that adds a little sorghum to make it lighter is still counted as clay. Litters that mix tofu with clay are counted separately as blends and are left out of this comparison.
The averages, test by test
| Test | Tofu and soy (9) | Clay (20) |
|---|---|---|
| Dust | 4.33 | 3.70 |
| Clumping | 4.17 | 4.35 |
| Odour | 4.28 | 4.38 |
| Tracking | 4.22 | 3.95 |
| Sustainability | 4.22 | 2.52 |
| Total out of 100 | 84.9 | 75.6 |
Scores are averages out of 5. A higher score is always better, so a high dust score means less dust.
Where tofu was ahead
Dust. This was the clearest performance gap. No clay litter scored a full 5 for dust, and 7 of the 20 scored 3. Two tofu litters scored 5, and none scored below 4.
Tracking. Tofu averaged 4.22 against 3.95 for clay. Our method links tracking closely to grain size: larger, denser granules travel less, and most tofu litters are pressed into pellets.
Sustainability. This was the widest gap of all, 4.22 against 2.52. Tofu litter is made from soybean fibre left over from making tofu and soy milk, so it is renewable and biodegradable. Bentonite clay is strip-mined and is neither. Thirteen of the 20 clay litters scored 2 for sustainability, and none scored above 4. We cover this test in more detail in how sustainable each litter material is.
Where clay was ahead
Clumping. Clay averaged 4.35 against 4.17. Four clay litters scored a full 5 for clumping; one tofu litter did.
Odour. Clay averaged 4.38 against 4.28. That is a small difference, and both groups include litters that scored a full 5.
The best clay still beat most tofu
Averages hide a wide spread. Clay totals ran from 62 to 94, and tofu totals from 76 to 98.
The top clay litter, Ever Clean Extra Strength, scored 94 and ranks No. 3 overall. It scored 5 for clumping, odour and tracking, and outscored 7 of the 9 tofu litters. Three clay litters made the top 10.
At the other end, the lowest-scoring tofu litter (76) still scored higher than 12 of the 20 clay litters.
The top two places overall both went to tofu: Tofu Cat Litter Australia, Original with 98 and Pidan Original Tofu Cat Litter with 96.
Is tofu litter better than clay?
On average, yes: tofu and soy litters scored 85 out of 100 against 76 for clay. The individual litter matters more than the material, though, and the best clay litter beat most tofu litters.
The rest of this section is our judgement, based on the scores above.
- If low dust or a lower environmental footprint matters most to you, tofu is the safer starting point. It was ahead on both, and the gap was large.
- If hard clumps matter most, clay has a small edge on average, but check the individual litter. The best tofu litters matched the best clay on clumping.
- The material alone does not decide the result. A good clay litter beat most tofu litters, and a weak clay litter scored 32 points below the best one. Look up the specific litter in the Litter Index before you buy.
One thing we do not recommend with any litter: flushing it. Some tofu brands say small amounts can be flushed, and we never recommend flushing cat waste.
To see two or three litters side by side, use the compare page. For what each material is made from and what to watch for, see litter types explained. If you are still deciding what matters most, read how to choose a cat litter.